Pinocchio’s met its end by the cruel, invisible hand of the free market. Their parent bar purchased by Stacker’s, these noble men of the calzone were thrust out onto the street. I ask you, did we really need another pub? There will never be another Pinocchio’s — unless you count the ones in Three Rivers, Ludlow and Springfield — but that’s not the point! Pinocchio’s of Amherst will always hold a special place in the Food Dude’s heart because they were the only ones in the world bold enough to make a chicken alfredo calzone.
Shrugging off convention, these tireless visionaries sought culinary perfection and nearly achieved it with their chicken alfredo calzone. With only a hint of mozzarella to confirm its “zone-hood,” these magical dough pockets were wonders to behold. Yet ... they were not perfect. Broccoli, the dish’s standard second fiddle, was a tolerable accompaniment to the savory chicken and rich creamy sauce, but the zone could never reach its zenith if burdened by the brocc.
For a while, I would simply order this calzone without broccoli. This was a delicious compromise indeed, but the dish lacked a certain je ne sais quoi. Then one day, inspired by Bertucci’s Gratinati, I decided to ask for tortellini instead of broccoli. The order-taker was a bit taken aback but eventually obliged, and what resulted was pure indulgent perfection. Out of Pinocchio’s womb sprang a creature of unparalleled succulence. I can only hope that one day I will be as proud of my real children as I was of my doughy, delicious brainchild.
Sadly, with the closing of Pinnochio’s, my creation will be forever lost to the annals of history. I just ... I just wish I could have said goodbye one last time. A recent health-kick had fostered a long hiatus between my heart-clogging progeny and I, and now I will never get another chance to indulge in its wonders. So goodbye old friend, I’ll pour a 40 of marinara on the curb for you.